Pivoting on Purpose: Lessons in Turnaround Management from the PenFed Veteran Incubator

Last week I had the privilege of standing in front of a room of veteran and military-spouse founders at Harvard University’s David Rubenstein Treehouse for the kickoff of the PenFed Foundation’s Boston Veteran Entrepreneur incubator. I was there to talk about pivoting. I left having learned as much as I taught.

If you have never been in a room like that, here is what it feels like. Everyone is building something real. Everyone has already made hard calls with incomplete information, usually in places a lot less comfortable than a conference room in Allston. And nearly everyone is quietly carrying the same question: “It isn’t working as fast as I hoped. Was the idea bad?”

My answer, and the thread running through this whole post, is simple. No traction is not a verdict. It is data you have not read yet.

That idea sits at the heart of how we work at Wood Consulting Group, whether we are serving as a fractional CFO for a founder looking for product-market fit, a fractional COO for a firm going through a leadership change, or leading a turnaround for a business that is running out of time. So I want to share the framework from the session, and then connect it to what we see every day with organizations in transition.

Reading the signal before you change anything

Think of an old car radio. The station is almost always broadcasting. The question is whether you are picking up the message or the static. Founders rarely miss signals completely. They misread them. They react too late when they are attached to the plan, and too early when they are rattled.

The first distinction I ask founders to make is between a reaction and a behavior.

    • A reaction costs the customer nothing: sign-ups, downloads, followers, a pitch that “went really well.”

    • A behavior costs the customer something: a repeat purchase, a conversion, a renewal, churn, what a customer costs you compared to what they are worth.

Reactions feel like signals. Behaviors actually are signals. When it has been quiet for weeks and one encouraging reaction finally shows up, the temptation to grab it is enormous. One signal in a void is not a trend. That is confirmation bias wearing a nice suit.

Four questions to ask, in order

Before anyone changes direction, I walk them through four questions. Most of the time, one of the first three ends the conversation.

    1. Work. You wrote the plan. Did you actually run it? A hundred sales calls planned and twenty made is an activity gap, not a broken business model.

    1. Advice. Does the person giving you advice have the data? A respected advisor with sharp business instincts who has never spoken to your customers is offering credibility, not evidence. You have talked to your customers. They have not.

    1. Allure. Is this shiny, or does it move you forward? I have watched a software company land a Fortune 500 partner and celebrate, only to discover red tape, compliance requirements nobody budgeted for, and no money flowing because the partner was a gateway, not a buyer. Meanwhile, the cash runway kept shrinking. Access isn’t revenue.

    1. Stage. Are you searching or scaling? Borrowing from Eric Ries and The Lean Startup: experiment while you search, commit once you scale. Read signals early and every pivot is cheap. Read them late and every pivot is expensive.

One foot planted

Ries describes a pivot as a structured course correction. I like a basketball version. Once you stop dribbling, one foot stays planted. The other foot can swing in any direction. You can turn your whole body, protect the ball and find the open teammate, all while anchored to one fixed point.

Your planted foot is what stays: where you are headed and what you have already learned about your customers. Your rotating foot is the one thing you are deliberately changing and testing. Lift both feet and you have traveled. That is not a pivot. It is a new company, and you just threw away everything you learned.

There are five places that rotating foot can go:

    • Customer: same problem, different buyer.

    • Problem: same buyer, different need.

    • Solution: same problem, different approach.

    • Channel: same everything, different path to the customer.

    • Price: same everything, different way of charging.

The pivot founders forget: price

One of my favorite stories involves a feed and seed store that started offering delivery almost as an afterthought. It took off. The customers had not changed, but the problem the store solved had. It was no longer just selling feed. It was getting heavy bags to exactly where each client needed them. The drivers even kept notes on how every client liked their bags stacked.

Here is the part that makes a CFO smile. The owners believed they were underpriced and were afraid to raise prices. Yet their delivery clients happily paid a premium over competitors, because the store had solved a problem those clients did not know they had. The value was there all along. It just had not been priced.

I see this constantly. Founders rebuild entire products when all they needed to change was a number.

Set the stop number first

Once you have named the change, the danger is swinging too far. So before running any test, I ask founders to write down four things: the assumption that failed, what they believe now in a single sentence, the smallest possible test, and the numbers that mean “keep going” and “stop,” each with a date attached.

Set the stop number first. If you set it after the results come in, you will always find a way to read the numbers that lets you keep going. That is not a character flaw. It is human nature, and it is exactly why discipline has to be built into the process instead of left to willpower.

To compare options, we used an Ideation Scorecard that weighs six factors: market proof, urgency, money, capability, speed and risk. Proof and urgency carry the most weight, because the two things that kill early ventures are building for a problem nobody urgently has and mistaking interest for demand.

We worked an example together: a veteran-owned mobile detailing business, eight months in, with flat weekend bookings and ninety days of runway. The option that felt safest won all the comfortable rows and very few of the ones that matter. The winner turned out to be a channel pivot toward fleet accounts. Same service, same crew, same equipment, a different buyer. And it became a test, not a commitment: ten calls to fleet managers in two weeks, stop if fewer than two pilots sign, and keep the weekend business running the whole time.

What this has to do with turnaround management

People sometimes treat startup pivots and corporate turnarounds as different worlds. In my experience, they are the same discipline running at different speeds.

A turnaround is a pivot under pressure, with less runway and more people depending on the outcome. The tools are nearly identical. Read the real signal underneath the noise. Separate the activity gap from the broken model. Decide what stays planted. Change one thing at a time so you can actually tell what worked. And know your cash position well enough to know how long you have to find out.

That last point is where strategic finance earns its keep. Almost every expensive pivot I have watched got expensive because someone built, leased or hired before anyone confirmed the problem. A good fractional CFO puts real economics underneath the decision: unit economics, cash runway, a rolling cash forecast and the stop numbers that keep the team honest. A good fractional COO makes sure the plan actually gets run, so you are judging the strategy and not an execution gap.

Supporting organizations during times of transition

At Wood Consulting Group, transition is where we do our best work. Our clients include founders searching for fit, family businesses navigating succession, professional service firms reshaping after a partner departure, trade businesses scaling past what spreadsheets can handle, and nonprofits adjusting to a change in funding. The circumstances differ. The underlying questions are remarkably consistent.

We serve as embedded fractional CFO, fractional COO and turnaround partners, not advisors on the sidelines. Our DECIDE™ framework (Direction, Economics, Capability, Decision Discipline, Execution) gives leadership teams a shared language for making hard calls and following through on them. The results are practical: clients who have cut days sales outstanding nearly in half, and a firm that grew its EBITDA margin from 5% to 21% while raising employee wages.

None of that started with a perfect plan. It started with reading the signal honestly and deciding, on purpose, what to change.

Resources from the session

If you want to work through this on your own venture, here are the tools we used in the room.

    • Contact us directly for a copy of this presentation. 

To the Boston cohort

Working with veteran entrepreneurs is a genuine honor. You bring a level of mission focus, resilience and accountability that most founders spend years trying to develop. Thank you to the PenFed Foundation team for building a program that gives these founders real tools, at no cost and without taking equity, and to Harvard for hosting us in such an inspiring space.

To every founder in the Boston cohort: I wish you the very best of success over the next six weeks and well beyond. Remember the takeaway. One planted foot. One rotating foot. One test. One number that means stop. That is pivoting on purpose.

And the offer I made in the room stands for anyone reading this. If you want a second set of eyes on a scorecard, a set of stop numbers or the economics underneath a big decision, reach out. It costs you nothing to ask.

Andrew Wood, MBA, MSF
Principal, Wood Consulting Group
andrew@woodcg.com · (617) 600-8488 · woodcg.com

More Posts

Reading is useful. Clarity is better.